Jury deliberations wrap up for the day in DeLee murder trial

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 7/16/2009 7:24 pm
Syracuse, New York (WSYR-TV) - Jury deliberations have ended for the day on Thursday in the trial of a man accused of killing a transgendered woman.

Dwight DeLee is accused of shooting and killing 22-year-old Lateisha Green last November. Green is transgendered, and prosecutors believe DeLee killed Green because of her lifestyle.

The trial started on Monday.

The prosecution and defense made their closing arguments Thursday morning, and jury deliberations ended around 5:00 p.m. Deliberations will continue Friday morning at 9:00 a.m.

NewsChannel 9's Jeff Kulikowsky will stay in the courtroom all day Friday, and we'll bring you the verdict here on 9WSYR.COM as soon as it comes in.

From July 15th, 2009

Both Sides Rest In Hate Crime Trial 7-15-09
Was killing a hate crime? 7-15-09
Day 3 of Testimony in Hate Crime Murder trial 7-15-09

SYRACUSE (AP/WSYR-TV) - Three people who were at a New York house party when a transgendered woman was murdered testified Wednesday that the Syracuse man accused of the crime directed an anti-gay slur at the victim.

However, none of those witnesses could positively say Dwight DeLee was the person who fired the shot that killed 22-year-old Lateisha (lah-TEE'-shuh) Green last November.

Meanwhile, Onondaga County Court Judge William Walsh said authorities were investigating threats made against prosecution witnesses, two of whom on Tuesday recanted prior statements they made to police that they saw DeLee shoot Green.

Walsh said the threatened witnesses "named names" and those names included at least one member of DeLee's family.

The judge warned that authorities could pursue criminal charges and told DeLee if he is linked to those threats "it will be very, very bad for your defense."

The developments came as testimony in the three-day trial ended. Attorneys were scheduled to deliver closing arguments Thursday. The case will then go to the jury for deliberations.

Prosecutors say DeLee, 20, fatally shot Green because of anti-gay bias. If convicted of a hate crime, DeLee would face additional prison time.

Erica Allison, 19, who lived at the house, said she heard DeLee refer to Green as a "faggot" moments before Green was shot. However, Allison said she never saw DeLee or anyone else with the gun, which belonged to her brother.

Allison said it was widely known that Green, who was born Moses Cannon, was a male living as a female. The night Green was shot she was wearing jeans and a T-shirt.

David Junious, 17, Allison's brother, said when the car with Green pulled up to the curb, "everyone started getting real loud. No one wanted them around." Witnesses testified people at the party had been drinking, some heavily.

Junious said he told DeLee about the gun in the house.

"After I told him about the gun, he said about shooting those faggots," Junious said. "He went up to the car and then everyone started running around and the car sped off."

However, Junious also said he did not see DeLee fire the gun, although he did see DeLee carrying the gun back into the house minutes later.

Police recovered the rifle from an upstairs bedroom at the house, where it was stuffed between a bed mattress and box spring.

A police detective who interrogated DeLee also testified. He told the jury DeLee denied the allegations but said “my life is over” – meaning he wouldn’t win the trial.

Another witness, Alyssa Davis, 19, said she heard a dark-skinned black man utter the slur and stick a rifle in the car window but never heard the gun fire. Davis said she didn't see the gunman's face, but recognized the voice as DeLee's and said he was the only dark-skinned male at the house at the time of the shooting.

Other witnesses have testified they heard others use the slur and that the gunman said nothing.

The defense's lone witness was a DNA expert who testified that a DNA examination of the gun found evidence of three contributors, but none were DeLee.

However, the expert admitted to prosecutors that DNA evidence could have been removed by wiping the gun down or by stuffing it in between the bed mattresses.

As the trial was winding down Wednesday, the U.S. Senate was considering legislation to extend current federal hate crimes protections to gays and other groups. The Matthew Shepard Hate Crimes Prevention Act, named after the gay Wyoming college student murdered in 1998, was proposed as an amendment to a $680 billion bill to approve defense programs.

The bill would expand federal hate crimes - currently defined as those motivated by race, color, national origin or religion - to include gender, sexual orientation, gender identity or disability.

A final vote on the measure wasn't expected until later in the week. The House passed a similar hate crimes bill in April.

July 14, 2009:

Murder As A Hate Crime Trial Day Two 7-14-09
Testimony in hate crime murder trial 7-14-09
Happening Now: Testimony in hate-crime murder trial Day 2 7-14-09
Hate crime murder trial continues 7-14-09

SYRACUSE, N.Y. (AP) - Two prosecution witnesses who told police they saw an accused 20-year-old man kill a transgendered woman recanted their statements on the witness stand Tuesday.

Siblings Johnny and Jasmine Gaston testified that investigators told them what to say about the shooting of 22-year-old Lateisha Green at a Syracuse house party last November.

Both gave signed statements to police identifying Dwight DeLee as the gunman. But on Tuesday, they insisted DeLee was involved and said someone else killed Green.

"They were telling me the story of what happened," said Johnny Gaston, who claimed he was coerced during eight hours of questioning.

Gaston and DeLee were friends who arrived at the party together. Jasmine Gaston is DeLee's girlfriend.

Perplexed prosecutors held several bench conferences with the judge as they questioned their two reluctant witnesses, who were among more than a dozen people who testified Tuesday at DeLee's hate crime murder trial in Onondaga County Court.

Earlier, another witness testified that she heard two men make disparaging remarks about gay people moments before a third man fired a single shot into the parked car in which Green was sitting.

But although she said she heard the two men using the word "faggot," Cassie Williams testified that she never heard the suspected gunman say anything.

Williams, 17, described the events surrounding the shooting but said she could not identifiy the killer, who wore a dark sweat shirt with the hood pulled over his head.

Mark Cannon, the victim's brother, testified Monday that DeLee was the person who fired the shot into the car. Cannon was wounded by the same bullet, which grazed his arm before hitting Green in the shoulder.

Medical Examiner Dr. Robert Stoppacher testified that the shot tore through Green's shoulder into her chest. The bullet passed through one lung, then her aorta, before lodging in the other lung, causing her to bleed to death.

Forensic experts also testified for the prosecution but they said they found no fingerprints on the rifle and could not conclusively link the gun to the bullet recovered from Green's body.

Prosecutors contend DeLee fatally shot Green because he thought she was gay. Born Moses Cannon, Green decided at age 16 to live as a woman, her family has said.

If DeLee is convicted of committing a hate crime murder, it would be only the second hate crime conviction involving the murder of a transgender person in the United States. Allen Andrade was convicted in May in Colorado of beating 18-year-old Angie Zapata to death with a fire extinguisher after discovering she was biologically male.

Under New York law, DeLee could face a minimum of 20 years to life in state prison if convicted of murder as a hate crime. Without the hate crime element, the minimum penalty is 15 years to life.

Monday, July 13, 2009

Murder As Hate Crime Trial Begins 7-13-09
Testimony to resume Wednesday in Hate Crime Murder Trial 7-13-09
Jury selection for hate crime trial 12PM Coverage 7-13-09
Jury selection for hate crime trial 7-12-09

Syracuse (WSYR-TV / AP) – Testimony will continue Tuesday in Onondaga County's first-ever hate crime murder trial. Dwight DeLee is charged with killing Moses Cannon, who lived as a woman named Lateisha “Teish” Green.

The first witness called to the stand was Mark Cannon, Green's brother. He gave a detailed description of being grazed by the same bullet that killed Green; the two were in a parked car with another person outside a house party in November when DeLee allegedly fired several rounds into the car.

He will return to the stand Tuesday to be cross-examined by DeLee's attorney.
The defense argues there's no evidence DeLee said or knew anything about Green's sexual orientation -- and that this isn't a hate crime.

The crime charges are relatively rare in New York, accounting for just one tenth of one percent of all reported crimes statewide last year. 

The conviction rate for hate crimes is also much lower -- only 13%, compared to 65% for all other crimes.

Under a New York law passed in 2000, a person can be charged with a hate crime if there's evidence the crime was based on race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender, religion, religious practice, age, disability or sexual orientation. A person convicted of a hate crime faces additional prison time.

Green's murder isn't being prosecuted as a hate crime because she was transgendered, said Michael Silverman, executive director of the New York City-based Transgender Legal Defense and Education Fund. Rather, it's being prosecuted as a hate crime because Green was perceived to be gay.

Neither New York state nor federal hate crime laws include gender identity or gender expression as explicitly protected hate crime categories, he said.

"It is inexcusable that transgendered people are excluded from hate crime protection in New York state while so many other types of people are protected," Silverman said.

Nearly 300 transgendered people filed reports of violence against them in 2008, according to the National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs.

Hate crime legislation that would protect transgender people from violence is currently pending in New York and at the federal level.

In New York, the Gender Expression Non-Discrimination Act has passed the Assembly and is awaiting Senate action.

At the federal level, the Matthew Shepard Act - named for a gay man killed in Wyoming in 1998 - would expand existing federal hate crime law to include crimes motivated by gender identity or sexual orientation. The House passed the bill in April, but the Senate has not yet scheduled a vote on it. The Obama administration has listed the bill as one of its top civil rights priorities.

If DeLee is convicted of committing a hate crime murder, it would be only the second hate crime conviction involving the murder of a transgender person in the United States, Silverman said.

Allen Andrade was convicted in May in Colorado of beating 18-year-old Angie Zapata to death with a fire extinguisher after discovering she was biologically male.

If DeLee is convicted of second degree murder as a hate crime, he'll face a minimum of 20 years to life in prison. If convicted of second degree murder, but not as a hate crime, DeLee would face a sentence of 15 years to life.

Share
Click 'Like' for Central New York news updates:


Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.